In the News

Court allows Siegelman release from prison pending appeal

March 28, 2008

[Assoc. Press, Johnson, 03/28/08]

A federal appeals court approved the release of former Alabama Gov. Don Siegelman on bond Thursday while he appeals his conviction in a corruption case.

The 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals said the former governor had raised "substantial questions of fact and law" in challenging his conviction.

The once-popular Democrat began serving a sentence of more than seven years last June on his conviction on six bribery-related counts and one obstruction count. Siegelman, 62, has been serving the sentence at a federal prison in Oakdale, La.

"It's a sweet day. He's an innocent man and he's been in prison for nine months," said Siegelman's attorney, Vince Kilborn.

Kilborn said Siegelman would be released from the Louisiana prison this morning after prison officials verify the court order with the 11th Circuit. Kilborn said Siegelman's wife, Lori, was planning to pick him up at the prison and "bring him back to his home in Birmingham so he can spend time with his family."

Federal prosecutors accused Siegelman of appointing then-HealthSouth CEO Richard Scrushy to a hospital regulatory board in exchange for Scrushy arranging $500,000 in contributions to Siegelman's campaign for a statewide lottery.

Scrushy, who was tried along with Siegelman, also was convicted on bribery counts and is serving a sentence of nearly seven years.

The 11th circuit, based in Atlanta, refused Thursday to reconsider an earlier ruling denying Scrushy's request to be released on bond while his conviction is being appealed. Scrushy attorney Art Leach said he received a copy of the latest order Thursday night.

"They said he has failed to prove he is not a flight risk," Leach said. He said he is disappointed his client will have to remain in prison for at least another six months while the case is appealed.

"I am extremely disappointed, particularly after they said in the Siegelman case that there are substantial issues on appeal," Leach said.

Siegelman was also convicted of a separate obstruction of justice charge concerning $9,200 he received from a lobbyist to help with the purchase of a motorcycle. His attorneys have said it was a legitimate transaction.

The former governor's release was approved on the same day the House Judiciary Committee announced that it wanted Siegelman to testify before Congress about possible political influence over his prosecution.

Siegelman has maintained that certain Republicans targeted him after he was elected governor in 1998 in an attempt to derail his political career. The House committee began reviewing his case as part of a broader investigation into allegations of political meddling in federal prosecutions.

Kilborn said he was trying to get word to Siegelman in the federal prison that the court had approved his release.

"I would love to see the expression on his face. That's going to be a moment in history I'd like to record," Kilborn said.

Kilborn noted that the order says Siegelman has raised substantial questions for the appellate court to consider in his appeal.

"I feel like we are getting closer to getting justice done. When you live with a case and have a step like this occur out of the blue, it's like lightning striking," Kilborn said.

Chief prosecutor Louis Franklin said he was "very disappointed" by the ruling, but still expects the appellate court will rule against Siegelman's appeal.

"I don't view this as a setback. The order is very short and concise and only deals with whether he is entitled to bond pending appeal," Franklin said.

The ruling Thursday by 11th Circuit Court Judges Susan Black and Stanley Marcus said Siegelman could be released under the same conditions that he was allowed to remain free for about a year after his June 2006 conviction. The amount of bond then was not disclosed, but restrictions were placed on his travel.

University of Alabama political scientist William Stewart, who attended much of Siegelman's trial, said he expects Siegelman will be free for a number of months because of the length and complexity of the appeal.

He said he believes Siegelman could avoid going back to prison if either Democratic presidential candidate Hillary Clinton or Barack Obama is elected.

"He'll be out for a long time and may never go back. If he's out until January and we elect Clinton or Obama, I expect he will be pardoned just like Scooter Libby was. I think either one is likely to pardon him," Stewart said.

Libby is a former White House aide whose prison sentence for perjury and obstruction of justice was commuted by President Bush.

With the House Judiciary Committee seeking testimony from Siegelman before Congress, he could ask federal probation officers for permission to go to Washington, D.C. He had been approved for trips out of state while he was awaiting sentencing.

The committee hopes to hear from Siegelman in May. Committee Chairman John Conyers, a Michigan Democrat, believes Siegelman "would have a lot to add to the committee's investigation into selective prosecution," committee spokeswoman Melanie Roussell said.

Kilborn said the former governor has agreed to testify.

"He's delighted to cooperate," he said. "There are no restrictions on questions they can ask him."

U.S. District Judge Mark Fuller of Montgomery had refused to allow Siegelman to remain free on appeal while challenging his conviction. But the 11th Circuit said Thursday he met the legal standard to be freed in the "complex and protracted" case.

The appeals process had been delayed for months after the court reporter during the trial died and the transcript was not completed as it normally would have.

The decision Thursday by the appeals court "is the correct step that should have been taken many months ago by Judge Fuller," said Alabama Democratic Party executive director Jim Spearman.

Alabama Republican Party chairman Mike Hubbard called the order "a formality."

"The former governor's release pending appeal does not change the conviction by a jury of his peers," Hubbard said.

| | Comments (2)
Comments
Don should never have spent one day in jail. Why does Hubbard say anything? As we already know the jury was not instructed by Fuller as they should have been. As for Franklin getting upset, it is apparent that with the decision of the 11th circuit, they stepped on someone's toes! Seems everyone of the real gulity ones are in the other party. Thank God, Don is back home in Alabama, where he belongs. As Don said, he had faith. The faith of knowing that he was not guilty and knowing that he had some of the most dedicated people in Alabama believing and working for him!

Posted by: Sarah Smith on March 28, 2008 3:50 PM

I have had a heavy heart ever since Don Siegelman was brought out of the courtroom in disgrace by Republican conspirators. Today my heart is not heavy any more and I am so thankful. May justice be served.

Posted by: Mike Davis on March 28, 2008 7:11 PM

Post a comment




Remember Me?